Names for Triggers/Actions

[AlexB]

I would love the ability to give some of my triggers a name or a custom label, much like you can name a layer. It should be an optional thing, since I don’t want to name ‘every’ trigger.

This would be particularly helpful when XP’s become complex with lots of conditional logic. Sometimes I’ll have a very large list of conditional triggers and it’s a real pain to click through each one and examine the triggers to determine the one I need to edit. Programmers can do this with comments in their code…we can’t really do this in Intuiface.

If I could name the trigger, or even have a little text on-hover, that’d be great. For example, I’d use it to label which triggers are Day 1 pass, Day 1 fail, Submit info IF xxx, Submit info If yyy.

It would certainly save a lot of time! Anyone else agree?

• YES
• No

[Seb]

I agree with you, although on the experiences I have been working on (which are not always “real-life XPs” like yours), if I’m in a situation where I need to do X times the same thing (similar scene content, similar action, similar trigger, …), X depending on the complexity of the “thing” and the available time I have to work on that XP, I try to:

• See if X is small enough that I should go with the “manual” method and duplicate my “thing” (scene, trigger, action…). X = 2 or 3, then I’m ok without notes to see which does what, using the trigger&action panel is fast enough to toggle between this triggers, for example.
• See if X is large enough (3+), or if I don’t know how big it can grow (based on customer new inputs), and if I should try to make that mechanism more generic and work with a real X value, using Excel, H-CMS, Global variables or any other Interface Asset (even a custom coded one if needed, like for the Memory-game). Then I have only 1 “thing” and no need for notes.

It’s not always possible to make this generic, or sometimes it “costs” too much (over-engineering) and it’s not worth it.

It’s also a very programmatic approach, not a designer one, that was engraved by one of my teachers:
“If you have more than one else in your if statement, you’re doing it wrong”

For the mode designer approach, having notes / labels / comments fields would definitely help, so +1 from me too on this suggestion

[AlexB]

Haha, you certainly took that to a new level!

But without thinking too much into it, it’s just a label to help identify my triggers
Some types of experiences are data driven or logic-based and therefore can require a lot of conditions.

Also consider that composer can slow down in these instances too, and I’ve seen 5+ seconds go by with a very strong pc before the action menu opens. Multiple that by hundreds of iterations and there’s a lot of time/frustration.

The label doesn’t need to be anything too complex. Even the design accelerators have a little notes field that shows hover text.

[Seb]

Alex, that’s actually exactly my point: the more the experience is “data-driven” or “logic-based”, the less “manual” conditions it should have, the less triggers it should have, the less “if then else if, else if, else if, else” it should have, to avoid having this performance issue in Composer, or just this complexity.

Let me take an example

A non-interactive QSR Menu board needs to change scene based on time of the day. The scheduling can be changed by the Composer user, and the original specs of the XP were:

• 6.30am to 10am: breakfast
• 10am to 11am: video (kitchen closed)
• 11am to 2.30pm: lunch
• 2.30pm to 4pm: video
• 4pm to 7pm: dinner
• 7pm to 6.30am: video

First approach: lots of triggers and conditions

It works, but it’s tedious to set and maintain, and indeed need to go over all triggers to find the right one if you need to edit it.
I’d love to have labels in this case!

Second approach: data driven.

Using an Excel sheet (or H-CMS, Airtable, Knack, …)

On the same button, filter the Excel based on clock time to get “the proper scene” to navigate to, and bing the go to scene action on that filter result

1 trigger, 3 actions and you can have as many timeslots as you need in your timetable. That’s generic and scalable.

Now as I said, this method isn’t always applicable and sometimes costs more than just a few copy & paste of triggers.

[AlexB]

Hey Seb, thanks for the example. I’ve built menu schedulers before and agree with you 100%.

But showing a single method of data triggers, in my humble opinion, doesn’t negate the idea that labels for triggers can be very helpful.

I’ve recorded a video for you to show you what I’m talking about. In these examples, using filtering doesn’t apply to the scenario. Conditional logic is needed.

You can watch the video here, and I’d love to hear your thoughts: Dropbox - TriggerNamesIdea-Why.mp4 - Simplify your life

[Louie_Smith]

[AlexB]

Hey @Seb ,
I’m trying to think of another feature that could accomplish this and more. What if you could “Group” actions? Therefore, you could name the group with a label, set a delay for the whole group, and move it up/down the list as a single unit…and even duplicate the entire group.

This way, complex sets of actions can be organized nicely, labeled for their function, and moved as a single unit.

[Seb]

You can “do that” already, using the @tosolini technique (yes, there’s a kind of copyright here, Paolo taught me that technique yeaaaaars ago)

• Create a button, place it outside of your scene.
• Name the button with something that makes sense
• Add a “button is released trigger” and all the actions you want to “group”
• On your original trigger, call the “simulate a tap” action on that button
• Bonus: you can move this button inside the scene to test your actions, independently from your original trigger

See an example in this sample, again © @tosolini
https://my.intuiface.com/marketplace/detail.aspx?name=Trade%20Show%20Wayfinder

[AlexB]

Ok, I guess I’ll throw in the towel on this idea. I’ll do my best to find another solution for this situation, it’s probably not that common to be honest anyways. Thanks for you assistance!

[AlexB]

I created a Mock-Up for what this could look like on the triggers/actions menu.

Just a simple hover-label to write a couple words. Super simple to tell what is happening without opening the T/A menu.

[Seb]

Thanks for that @AlexB, I’ll make sure @alban & the team gets it

[AlexB]

Thanks!
FYI, after looking again at this, I suppose the Label text input box could go below, or near the Trigger item at the top left. It’s a little easier to see up there.